White House, analysts' tax forecasts clash
The White House has promoted President Donald Trump's tax cut plan with a forecast of faster US economic expansion and wage growth, as independent analysts say the plan would swell the budget deficit and provide little spark to the economy.
WASHINGTON, DC - [Reuters] The White House has promoted President Donald Trump's tax cut plan with a forecast of faster US economic expansion and wage growth, as independent analysts say the plan would swell the budget deficit and provide little spark to the economy.
The rival projections reflect the many unknowns swirling around the plan, expected to be unveiled in legislative form on Wednesday. Republicans were still undecided on some of the hardest parts, such as how to pay for the costly cuts proposed.
Weeks and possibly months of debate lie ahead for a project that Trump promised to tackle in his 2016 election campaign. In September, he unveiled a rough framework for cutting taxes. Now, he wants Congress to approve a bill, which would mark his first major legislative victory, before the end of the year.
The Trump plan for tax cuts of the sort normally reserved for times of economic recession is taking shape in Congress amid signs the economy is already growing briskly.
Gross domestic product increased at a 3 per cent annual rate in the July-September period, supported by strong business spending on equipment, the Commerce Department said on Friday.
The economic recovery begun under then president Barack Obama after the 2007-2009 recession is in its eighth year and showing little signs of fatigue amid a tightening labour market.
"It's hard to say that we need to have tax cuts at the individual level ... You don't need to provide further fiscal stimulus when the economy is already strong," said Bernard Baumohl, chief global economist at the Economic Outlook Group in Princeton, New Jersey.
Faced with improving economic prospects, Republicans have shifted their rhetoric on tax cuts away from getting the economy moving again to keeping it on an expansion track.
An analysis released by White House economic adviser Kevin Hassett said slashing the top federal corporate tax rate and letting businesses write off the full cost of most capital investments immediately, as proposed in the plan, would bring faster growth and higher wages.
Hassett's projections envisioned a 3 per cent to 5 per cent increase in GDP that, over 10 years, could represent an additional $US700 billion to $US1.2 trillion in economic output.
But the Tax Policy Centre, a non-profit Washington think tank, released an analysis that concluded the Trump tax plan would not produce a significant, permanent economic boost.
The group said the plan would reduce federal tax revenue by roughly $US2.4 trillion over the next decade and by more than $US3 trillion in the decade after that, adding significantly to a US national debt that already exceeds $US20.4 trillion.
The centre said Trump's tax cuts would drive new activity at first, but that the impact would be blunted in later years by rising deficits, forcing more federal borrowing to finance the tax cuts and driving up borrowing costs for the private sector.
Hassett told reporters he does not expect tax reform to add significantly to the deficit. But he conceded that it would become "a big negative" if economic growth failed to materialise and the debt level soared.
The framework of Trump's plan unveiled in September called for reducing the corporate tax rate to 20 per cent from 35 per cent, the small business rate to 25 per cent from up to 39.6 per cent and the top individual rate to 35 per cent from 39.6 per cent.
It also called specifically for repealing the estate tax on inheritances and the alternative minimum tax, both of which are typically paid by the country's highest-income earners.
Less clear were the plan's proposals to reduce the number of tax brackets, enhance the child tax credit and possibly put new limits on popular 401(k) (superannuation) retirement pension plans.
Because details of the unfinished tax legislation are unknown, its economic impact is unclear, said Omer Eisner, chief market analyst at Commonwealth Foreign Exchange in Washington.
Hours after the Commerce Department reported stronger-than-expected third quarter US economic growth of 3 per cent, Hassett said the data did not undercut the need for tax cuts.
He said economic expansion and stronger stock market performance could be undermined if the Republican-controlled Congress fails to enact the tax cuts.
"Firms are optimistic both because of regulatory reform but also because they expect corporate tax reform and overall tax reform," Hassett said. "The thing that I'm worried about is that if those expectations prove to be incorrect, then I would expect business capital spending to go back to a disappointing path and equity markets to decline as well."
Kevin Brady, chairman of the US House of Representatives tax committee, said progress was being made toward satisfying Republicans who have held back support for the tax plan because it could end a deduction for state and local taxes. "I'm hopeful ... we can find a good solution for them," Brady said.
©[2017] Thomson Reuters. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of Thomson Reuters content, including by framing or similar means, is prohibited without the prior written consent of Thomson Reuters. Thomson Reuters and the Kinesis logo are trademarks of Thomson Reuters and its affiliated companies with a hypertext link from the copyright notice to the detailed notice and disclaimer set out below:
Licensee acknowledges and agrees that text or Multimedia from Thomson Reuters are for the personal, non-commercial use of Users and not otherwise for copying, archiving, storing, republication, re-distribution, re-dissemination, publication or any other commercial exploitation in any form or by any method whatsoever by Licensee, Users, or any other persons. Thomson Reuters will not be held liable in any way to the User or to any third party or to any person who may receive information in Service to any person whatsoever, for any delays, inaccuracies, errors or therefrom or in the transmission or delivery of all or any part thereof or for any damages arising from any of the foregoing or occasioned thereby.